Want to learn the ideas in The Protestant Ethic And The Spirit Of Capitalism better than ever? Read the world’s #1 book summary of The Protestant Ethic And The Spirit Of Capitalism by Max Weber, Talcott Parsons, R.H. Tawney here.
Read a brief 1-Page Summary or watch video summaries curated by our expert team. Note: this book guide is not affiliated with or endorsed by the publisher or author, and we always encourage you to purchase and read the full book.
Video Summaries of The Protestant Ethic And The Spirit Of Capitalism
We’ve scoured the Internet for the very best videos on The Protestant Ethic And The Spirit Of Capitalism, from high-quality videos summaries to interviews or commentary by Max Weber, Talcott Parsons, R.H. Tawney.
1-Page Summary of The Protestant Ethic And The Spirit Of Capitalism
Overall Summary
Part 1, Section 1
Weber noted that in Europe and America, Protestants held more managerial, skilled labor, and capital investment positions than Catholics. He admitted that there may have been historical reasons for this phenomenon—one such possible reason is that the Protestant Reformation was successful in wealthy cities, meaning that Protestants may have started with higher net capital. However, Calvinism exerts a stricter control over daily life than Catholicism did; therefore it does not seem logical to assume that they would thrive in free markets.
Although Weber acknowledges historical reasons for the wealth of Protestants, he notes that there are some things history cannot explain. First, although Catholics make up a large percentage of the population in many countries, they do not participate in middle-class professions as much as Protestants. Additionally, while Protestant factory workers can rise to become skilled laborers and earn a good living through hard work and ambition, Catholic craftsmen remain at the same level throughout their lives. He argues that this indicates differences in mental characteristics between religious groups.
Max Weber, a German economist, is trying to determine the reasons why Catholics and Protestants differ in their economic outcomes. He observes that Catholics are more likely to be ascetic, which makes them less acquisitive. Asceticism means living a simple life without material things. As a result, they’re less engaged with worldly affairs than Protestants. This leads to differences between the two groups: Protestants are seen as more hedonistic or pleasure-seeking because of Calvinist movements and Puritan churches. However, this stereotype isn’t true for all Protestants today.
Weber observed that some of the most pious groups, especially Calvinists, were also very good at business. These people used their piety to make money and spread their religion. Quakers and Mennonites are examples of this type of group as well. Weber will examine why these groups are so successful in his next chapter.
Part 1, Section 2
Weber finds the phrase “the ‘spirit’ of capitalism” to be somewhat pompous, but he uses it anyway because he wants to describe a particular mindset. Obviously, people have different mindsets; Weber only wants to capture the essence of this capitalist mindset. The best way to demonstrate what he means by the capitalist spirit is through an example.
Weber includes a quote from Benjamin Franklin, who was famous for his financial acumen. In this quote, he gives advice on how to be successful with money and credit. He also says that you should always try to make more money and improve your position in life.
Weber uses Franklin’s sermon to criticize the American ethos. He argues that Americans believe in accumulating wealth as a civic duty, which is what he considers to be the essence of capitalism. According to Weber, this capitalist spirit is hypocritical because it offers only pragmatic advice on how one should make money and does not consider moral issues at all. However, Franklin believed that his doctrine came from God and was meant for everyone who wanted success in life. Therefore, making money was not just an ideal but also a way of living up to God’s expectations for people.
Weber argues that the main ethic of a capitalist society is to work hard. However, Weber doesn’t think capitalism created this value; rather, he believes it was already present in societies like the early United States and England. Franklin’s countrymen applauded his work ethic because they saw him as an honest man who worked hard for what he had.